“Dear Allegra,” he captioned the photo. “Some things never change. Except, a lot changed, and then it got very similar, but very different, but better, and now, your finger’s a bit heavier. And not just because of all the pecan pie. What a Thanksgiving. I love your laugh. I love your heart. I love your family. I love you. Looking forward to wifing you.
He also posted several videos from right after the proposal, which included some prime shots of Allegra’s engagement ring.
Allegra also posted the same engagement photos on Instagram. “I get to grow older with the love of my life, for the rest of my days,” she wrote. “I adore you Clay. Thankful is an understatement.”
It appears like the two might have met while starring in the short film, Life is Not a Musical: The Musical in 2010. The film was Clayton’s first post-graduation role since Lizzie McGuire. Congrats to the happy couple!